Friday, January 15, 2010

Ruined: A novel

I just had one of those book moments when the suspense is so good I can't stop reading, and then suddenly, the book is over. It is always bittersweet--it feels good to have the story resolved, but I always feel like I want more---more details, more story, more of what happens next.

But what happens when you are given exactly what you want? It's kind of like eating that extra piece of Halloween candy when you've already gorged yourself. You think it will satisfy you, but really all you're given yourself is a belly ache. I always think of the final book of Harry Potter in that way. I wanted to know what happened to Harry after, but when Rowling describes Harry as an adult, it doesn't feel right to me. It seems like she wanted to tie the series up with a bow, and life isn't like that--I detest when a book/television show/movie feels the need to resolve everything in a "It all works out in the end" conclusion.

Not to make a dated reference, but the lack of such a conclusion is what I really enjoyed about the Sopranos finale. The show's ending left as many questions as it answered, and isn't that what life is all about? I'm not saying that I want the books I read to have the conflicts completely unresolved (What would be the purpose of reading then?), but I wish that writers would refrain from giving us epilogues in which everyone lives happily ever after.

At this point, you are probably looking at the title of this post and thinking, "What does this rant have to do with the aforementioned novel?" I won't be going into to detail about the plot of the novel, since I will be doing an audio booktalk (which you will be able to find on the PHS library website), but I will say I was really enjoying Ruined: A novel by Paula Morris until the last chapter and the epilogue. The resolutions happened way too fast, and while they made sense, for the most part, they just seemed tied up a little too neatly.

BUT I really liked the New Orleans setting of the book, and I relished reading a book that was a ghost story and a murder mystery all wrapped in one. However, the characterization of the main character Rebecca was somewhat complex, but most other characters were one dimensional.

Was this a good book? I've read better; I've read worse. It was a page turner, but would not be one that I would feel the need to read again.